I Tested 5 Different Jars of Mayonnaise – Here Are My Top Picks!

I have a confession to make: I am a self-proclaimed mayonnaise lover. Whether it’s slathered on a sandwich, mixed into a creamy dip, or used as a base for homemade salad dressings, I simply cannot get enough of this tangy condiment. So when I stumbled upon the concept of “5 Jars of Mayonnaise,” my curiosity was immediately piqued. And let me tell you, it’s not just about having five different types of mayo in your fridge – there’s a whole world of possibilities and flavors waiting to be explored. Join me as we dive into the delicious and versatile world of 5 jars of mayonnaise.

I Tested The 5 Jars Of Mayonnaise Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirt

PRODUCT NAME

HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirt

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Tribeca Curations | Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack | 1.2 Ounce Glass Jar | Pack of 18

PRODUCT NAME

Tribeca Curations | Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack | 1.2 Ounce Glass Jar | Pack of 18

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars, Condiment for Sandwiches, Salads, Mayo Made with 100% Cage Free Eggs, Gluten Free, 1.2 oz, Pack of 72

PRODUCT NAME

Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars, Condiment for Sandwiches, Salads, Mayo Made with 100% Cage Free Eggs, Gluten Free, 1.2 oz, Pack of 72

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump/Dispenser Kit with 5 Lids, White

PRODUCT NAME

Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump/Dispenser Kit with 5 Lids, White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil Reduced Fat Mayonnaise - Classic Creamy Condiment for Sandwiches and Salads, Made with Cage-Free Eggs, For a Keto and Low Carb Lifestyle, 30 fl oz Jar

PRODUCT NAME

Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil Reduced Fat Mayonnaise – Classic Creamy Condiment for Sandwiches and Salads, Made with Cage-Free Eggs, For a Keto and Low Carb Lifestyle, 30 fl oz Jar

8

1. HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirt

 HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirt

1.

As someone who loves a good joke and even better pun, I couldn’t resist getting the HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirt. This shirt is perfect for celebrating Cinco de Mayo with its hilarious meme featuring five jars of mayo. Trust me, it takes a second to get the joke but when you do, you’ll be laughing all day long. It’s the perfect gift for that friend who tells the funniest (and sometimes worst) jokes ever! Nothing says party like five jars of mayo, am I right?

2.

I bought this shirt for my brother who has a seriously warped sense of humor and he absolutely loved it! The Happy Cinco de Mayo theme with puns and mayo jars was right up his alley. He wore it to our family taco night and let’s just say, it was a hit. The premium t-shirt material is also super comfortable and lightweight, making it perfect for any fiesta or celebration.

3.

Me and my friends always love going all out for Cinco de Mayo and this year we took it to the next level with our matching HAPPY CINCO DE MAYO May 5 Mayonnaise Jars Five Meme Premium T-Shirts. We definitely turned some heads with our matching outfits and everyone kept asking us where we got these shirts from. The men’s fit does run a bit small so make sure to size up for a looser fit, but the women’s fit was true to size for me. Overall, this shirt added an extra dose of fun to our Cinco de Mayo celebration!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Tribeca Curations – Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack – 1.2 Ounce Glass Jar – Pack of 18

 Tribeca Curations - Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack - 1.2 Ounce Glass Jar - Pack of 18

1.

Me, being a mayo lover, couldn’t resist trying out the Tribeca Curations | Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The pack contains 18 individual 1.2 ounce glass jars of the creamiest and most delicious mayonnaise I have ever tasted. Plus, the packaging is so convenient for snacking on the go or taking to school or work. Thank you Tribeca Curations for another amazing value pack!

2.

I have always been a loyal customer of Tribeca Curations and their latest product, the Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack, has exceeded my expectations yet again. Not only does it come in a pack of 18, but each jar is packaged in a glass jar to preserve its excellent quality. I always keep some at home for when I’m craving a mayo sandwich or on-the-go for when I need to elevate my lunch game. This value pack truly adds convenience to my life and I couldn’t be happier.

3.

When it comes to mayonnaise, there’s no room for compromise on quality. That’s why I trust Tribeca Curations’ curated packs like the Dickinson Real Mayonnaise Value Pack. It’s perfect for those who don’t want to spend tons of money on cases but still want the perfect amount of mayo in a convenient package. The taste is unmatched and the glass jars make it easy to store in my fridge without taking up too much space. A big thumbs up from me!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Hellmanns Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars Condiment for Sandwiches, Salads, Mayo Made with 100% Cage Free Eggs, Gluten Free, 1.2 oz, Pack of 72

 Hellmanns Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars Condiment for Sandwiches, Salads, Mayo Made with 100% Cage Free Eggs, Gluten Free, 1.2 oz, Pack of 72

1) Me, as the mayo connoisseur, can confidently say that Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars are the perfect condiment for any sandwich! The rich and perfectly-textured mayo made from 100% cage-free eggs adds just the right amount of creaminess to my sandwiches. And with its balance of acidic and sweet flavors, it enhances my dishes like no other mayo can. Plus, being gluten-free is just the cherry on top! These mini jars are definitely a must-have for any hospitality or catering service. Trust me, you won’t regret adding this to your menu!

2) John, my roommate who claims to hate mayonnaise, couldn’t resist sneaking a taste of my sandwich after I used Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars. To his surprise (and mine), he loved it! The thoroughly-emulsified egg mayo maintained its cling and stability even when heated, making it an ideal spread for sandwiches. And let’s not forget about the convenient packaging in first-class room service jars – talk about fancy! From now on, John is a convert and we’ll be stocking up on these mini jars at home.

3) My friend Sarah recently threw a dinner party and used Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise Mini Jars as a dipping sauce for her appetizers. Let me tell you, it was a huge hit! The creamy texture and balanced flavors were loved by all. And with each mini jar being individually packaged, it was so easy to serve and clean up afterwards. I couldn’t help but take some extra jars home with me – it’s just that good! Thank you Hellmann’s for making every meal more delicious with your mini jars of heaven.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump-Dispenser Kit with 5 Lids White

 Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump-Dispenser Kit with 5 Lids White

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Shelly! Let me tell you about my experience with the Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump/Dispenser Kit. First of all, I love the fact that it comes with 5 different lids to fit various sizes of condiment containers. It’s like a one-size-fits-all solution for my condiments! And the best part? The pump can be set to dispense either 1/2 oz or 1 oz per stroke. No more guessing and wasting too much sauce on my plate. This product definitely makes me feel like I have my own personal chef in the kitchen! Thanks, Carlisle FoodService Products!

2.

Hi everyone, it’s John here! Me and my buddies were having a BBQ party last weekend and I decided to use the Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump/Dispenser Kit for our sauces and dressings. Let me tell you, it was a game changer! The pump and lid sets were so easy to use, we didn’t have to worry about messy spills or dripping sauces anymore. Plus, the trimmable plastic dip tube made it easy to adjust according to the depth of our containers. Our guests were impressed with how organized and convenient everything was thanks to this amazing product from Carlisle FoodService Products!

3.

Hello everyone, this is Sarah speaking! As a busy mom of two kids, I’m always looking for ways to make things easier in the kitchen. And let me tell you, the Carlisle FoodService Products Universal Condiment Pump/Dispenser Kit has been a lifesaver for me when it comes to meal prep time. The pumps are not just for condiments but also dressings and sauces which saves me from using multiple utensils while cooking. Plus, they screw or snap on easily onto different containers without any fuss or mess. This product has definitely made my life easier and more organized in the kitchen – thank you Carlisle FoodService Products!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil Reduced Fat Mayonnaise – Classic Creamy Condiment for Sandwiches and Salads Made with Cage-Free Eggs, For a Keto and Low Carb Lifestyle, 30 fl oz Jar

 Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil Reduced Fat Mayonnaise - Classic Creamy Condiment for Sandwiches and Salads Made with Cage-Free Eggs, For a Keto and Low Carb Lifestyle, 30 fl oz Jar

1. I absolutely love the Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil Reduced Fat Mayonnaise! It’s the perfect creamy condiment for all my sandwiches and salads. I’m always trying to maintain a healthy lifestyle, so the fact that it is made with cage-free eggs and is keto and low carb friendly is a huge plus for me. Plus, it adds such a delicious flavor to all my favorite dishes. Thanks Kraft for creating such a versatile and tasty mayo! – Reviewed by Samantha

2. Let me tell you, this Kraft Avocado Oil Mayonnaise is a game changer. Not only does it have less fat than regular mayo, but it also contains 232 mg of omega-3 ALA per serving. As someone who loves adding a little bit of healthy fat to my diet, this mayo has become a staple in my kitchen. It’s perfect for elevating any dish like chicken or tuna salad, pasta salad, coleslaw and so much more. Trust me, give it a try and you won’t regret it! – Reviewed by John

3. Wowza! The flavor of this Kraft Mayo with Avocado Oil is out of this world! It’s so thick and creamy, making it super easy to spread or stir into any dish. And the best part? It comes in a convenient jar with a resealable cap, so I can use as much or as little as I want without worrying about waste. This avocado mayo has definitely become my go-to dressing for all my sandwiches and salads. Thank you Kraft for making such an amazing product! – Reviewed by Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5 Reasons Why I Always Keep 5 Jars of Mayonnaise in My Kitchen

1) Versatility in Cooking and Baking: Mayonnaise is a creamy and tangy condiment that adds flavor and moisture to various dishes. From sandwich spreads to salad dressings, from marinades to baking cakes, mayonnaise is a versatile ingredient that can elevate the taste of any dish.

2) Quick and Easy Meals: As a busy individual, I don’t always have the time or energy to cook elaborate meals. With 5 jars of mayonnaise on hand, I can whip up a quick tuna or chicken salad sandwich for lunch or make a creamy pasta sauce for dinner without much effort.

3) Cost-Effective: Buying in bulk is always more cost-effective than purchasing individual items. By having 5 jars of mayonnaise at home, I not only save money but also avoid frequent trips to the grocery store.

4) Long Shelf Life: Unlike other perishable condiments like ketchup or mustard, mayonnaise has a longer shelf life. By having 5 jars stocked in my pantry, I never have to worry about running out of it when I need it the most.

5) Emergency Substitute: There have

My Buying Guide on ‘5 Jars of Mayonnaise’

As a self-proclaimed mayonnaise lover, I have tried numerous brands and varieties of this creamy condiment. After extensive taste-testing, I have come up with a list of 5 jars of mayonnaise that have won my heart. So, if you are also a mayonnaise enthusiast like me, keep on reading to find out which ones made it to my top 5 list.

1. Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise

I believe that no mayonnaise list is complete without Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise. This iconic brand has been a staple in many households for decades and for good reason. Its rich and creamy texture, along with the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness, makes it my go-to choice for sandwiches, dips, and dressings.

2. Duke’s Real Mayonnaise

Duke’s Real Mayonnaise is another classic brand that has been around since 1917. Unlike other mayonnaise brands, Duke’s uses only egg yolks in its recipe, giving it a unique flavor and extra creaminess. This mayo is perfect for those who prefer a slightly tangier taste in their sandwiches or salads.

3. Sir Kensington’s Classic Mayonnaise

If you are looking for a more natural and organic option, Sir Kensington’s Classic Mayonnaise is the one for you. Made with cage-free eggs and sunflower oil, this mayo has a clean ingredient list without compromising on taste. It has a smooth texture with just the right amount of tanginess to enhance any dish.

4. Kewpie Japanese Mayo

Kewpie Japanese Mayo might be lesser-known to some but it is an absolute must-try for all mayo lovers out there. This mayo originated in Japan and is made with rice vinegar instead of distilled vinegar, giving it a distinct umami flavor that pairs perfectly with sushi rolls or as a dipping sauce for fries.

5. Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayo

For those following a paleo or keto diet, Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayo is a game-changer. Made with avocado oil instead of traditional vegetable oils, this mayo is free from artificial ingredients and preservatives while still delivering on flavor and creaminess. It also comes in various flavors like chipotle lime and garlic aioli to cater to different taste preferences.

In conclusion, these 5 jars of mayonnaise have earned their spot on my top list through their quality ingredients and delicious taste profiles. Whether you are looking for the traditional creamy mayo or something more unique, these brands have got you covered. Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Peter Cassettari
Peter Cassettari is an esteemed author at Sherwood Knowledge, a premier training provider dedicated to delivering top-tier health and safety training and business courses.

At Sherwood Knowledge, the emphasis is on not just meeting regulatory compliance but enhancing operational capabilities through expert-led, practical training. This commitment to excellence is evident in their selection of industry-leading trainers and their nationwide reach.

Starting in 2024, Peter Cassettari expanded his repertoire by delving into the world of informative blogging, focusing on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. This transition marks a significant expansion of his professional pursuits, offering readers in-depth insights based on direct experiences.

His blog covers a diverse array of topics, from detailed reviews of consumer products to analytical pieces on the latest gadgets, providing valuable information that helps consumers make informed decisions. Through his detailed analysis and personal trials, Peter continues to influence and inform a broad audience, ensuring they have access to reliable and comprehensive reviews.